How does a body tell God's story?

I bumped into a Facebook ad for a book that upset me. It will be released in a few days: Our Bodies Tell God's Story: Discovering the Divine Plan for Love, Sex, and Gender, by Christopher West. He is Catholic and has made a career out of defending the Church's teachings on gender and sexuality, filtered through John Paul II's Theology of the Body lecture series. I am continuing to discover and gain curiosity about the power that the Theology of the Body wielded on generations of conservative Catholics who wish to puff up and dress up the credibility of gender essentialism, homophobia, queerphobia, and moral prohibitions on contraception.  I think what caught my attention and disturbed me the most is the title. What assumptions lie behind the notion that our bodies tell God's story? It is a beautiful notion. But therein lies my uneasiness. It is sinister to twist this creative notion that our bodies tell God's story into the notion that our bodies as they are now indicate a divine plan of gender complementarity and gender essentialism.

I cannot abide this twisting. The apostle Paul teaches us that something astonishing has happened. In Christ there is a new creation. There is no "male and female." In Christ the rules of creation in Genesis 1 are not fulfilled: they are subverted and remade from the inside out. It was utterly and unthinkably unnatural that God would do this. In Christ, God had a body. God was a body. God is a body. And now that Christ is risen into the right hand of the Father, God will always be a body. This is the body who enters biological death and is spit out as glory. God comes in the Body of the Church, the Body of the Sacraments, the Body of the Word. This means that if our bodies are to tell the story of God, they must not be according to the flesh. The biological determinism of a fallen world is of the flesh. It is not how our bodies tell God’s story. They must be different from worldly expectations of how bodies tell stories. It is not bodies society privileges according to heteronormative standards that are the normative utterances of God’s story. It is the bodies who are Other, queer, desperate, poor, hungry, yearning, loving, hopeless, struck down, destroyed: these are the bodies who tell the story of God because this was the body Christ chose to suffer and die in. When we listen to these bodies, we listen to God. When we listen to the Word and take it into ourselves, our bodies are remade so that they may be chapters the divine story, so that we do not boast in ourselves but become grafted into the humble boasting Who is the Word.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

"Buddhisms: An Introduction" Review

Pentecost Sunday, Year A

Coffee with Calvin in Advent: preface