"Buddhisms: An Introduction" Review

I have been spending a lot of time with this book by John Strong lately. Among the Eastern religions Buddhism personally interests me the most, and this book attracted me because I have been been acquainted with some of the basics of Buddhism and wanted a meatier overview of the differences between different branches of the religion. For this reason I believe "Introduction" is a misleading because the topics covered in this book are more complex and better suited for a student who has some education in Buddhism rather than someone going in cold. Perhaps "Overview" would have been a better subtitle.

Regarding content, what I do appreciate about this book is its commitment to the diversity of Buddhism. The opening chapter introduces us to the major pilgrimage site of Lumbini in Nepal, where Buddha was born. The irony is that while this site brings together Buddhists from all over the world, Lumbini contains a complex of buildings and monastic communities that are divided based on region and sect. A central canal divides the site, and on one side of the canal are the Mahayana traditions while on the other side are the Theravada traditions. To me this opening chapter is an ingenious way of tangibly showing readers the divisions in Buddhism and helping them understand that Buddhism is not a monolithic religion.

Other portions of the book that I really enjoyed were the chapters on overcoming the Buddha's absence and Mahayana doctrinal developments. Chapter 3 is about the absence of the Buddha after he died and how Buddhists dealt with this loss by making substitutes for Buddha: sutras, relics, images, anticipation of the next eon's Buddha, and of course the content of the Dharma. I believe that this theme of searching (perhaps even compensating) for Buddha's absence is very profound because it shows that Buddhists saw the potency of their religious path as being intrinsically tied to the presence of and devotion to their founder. Even though Buddha was gone into the bliss of nirvana, he must still be here somehow, teaching and guiding and abiding. The sense of longing is palpable to me and captures the paradox of how we process the loss of a loved one. We know the departed cannot be fully here, and yet we still desire and experience modes of presence.

Chapter 9 is about Mahayana doctrinal developments and I like this chapter because it shows me how wild the Mahayana can be! Whether it is Nagarjuna's hard-earned  philosophical conclusion that nirvana and samsara have no distinction, the assertion that the buddha nature of all beings forms an eternal "self", or the Lotus Sutra's famous description of expedient means, some Mahayana teachings and branches seem so far from the ancient Indian intellectual context of early Buddhism that I wondered if I was even studying the same religion anymore. These stark differences raise the question of how continuity between a religion's beginnings and new developments are maintained. Mahayana teachings are clearly not exactly identical to early Buddhism, and yet Mahayana devotees will state that their doctrine is what Buddha taught. The interplay between the old and the new is one of the fascinating paradoxes of a religion that spreads to places and times far beyond its original context.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Pentecost Sunday, Year A

Coffee with Calvin in Advent: preface