My Favorite Scene From Black Panther



So I think Black Panther is one of the best films in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, easily in the top five. Unlike most other MCU movies it tries to be more than popcorn entertainment by raising pointed political questions. Moreover, it's a special film in the superhero genre not only because it features political themes (as many other great entries in the genre do), but because it features political themes centered around Blackness. The conflict between T'Challa and N'Jadaka/Killmonger is really a conflict about what it means to be Black, how to be Black in a world that systematically does not allow Black people to thrive. I could say more about this central conflict and other elements that make this film excellent but I really want to focus on my favorite moment. I've been thinking about it and how it made me feel ever since a co-worker mentioned that she saw the film for the first time a few weeks ago and I got excited about it all over again.

The moment is centered in the spirituality of Wakanda, of which we receive brief but tantalizing glimpses. When T'Challa becomes king he undergoes an important ritual where he is buried in sand and drinks from the heart-shaped herb to enter a spiritual realm, the Ancestral Plane, to commune with his ancestors, especially his beloved father whom he idolizes as a Mufasa-like figure. This scene is a joyous moment of reunion.

When Killmonger undergoes the same ritual after usurping T'Challa I wondered what the spiritual realm would look like to him. I assumed the film would take us to the same place, the same comforting Wakandan fields. It frankly would have been the safer creative choice.

I was not expecting Killmonger to return back to the place of his trauma. My heart broke when I saw the adult N'Jadaka opening the door of that Oakland apartment.

Why does this moment move me so much? I think it shows us how cut off Killmonger is from his identity. T'Challa experiences the spiritual realm as a world of freedom and communion. He is in the open fields of home. The presence of the previous Black Panthers comforts him in the warm glow of their eyes. He has the rare privilege of knowing in this life that his father's death was not in vain.

But N'Jadaka experiences the Ancestral Plane as a box. He confined to the walls of the Oakland complex and the walls of his trauma and the walls of King T'Chaka and Zuri's decision to abandon him. There is no council of ancestors to greet N'Jadaka because his only link to what makes him Wakandan is a father who was double-crossed by his own countrymen. Killmonger's reunion with his father does not provide warmth or affirmation or closure, but only lingering doubt about whether N'Jobu approves of what Killmonger became: "I should have taken you home long ago... instead, we are both abandoned here."

N'Jobu is right. As Zuri said to T'Challa, N'Jadaka is the abandoned one, the one left behind to maintain the lie.

In this scene I believe Killmonger is a symbol for the legacy of slavery and colonialism and racism. It's not a perfect parallel because Killmonger was abandoned by Wakandans, his own kind, while Black slaves were abandoned due to the oppression of white people. But like Killmonger, Black Americans for generations have known they come from greatness but do not know how to fully link themselves to their heritage. There is the foreboding existential knowledge that African American life exists at all in the USA because of a violently impaired communion with its motherland. As James Baldwin said, "To be a Negro in this country and to be relatively conscious is to be in a rage almost all the time." Maybe there is always a little bit of Killmonger in the Black American experience.

But is that all it means to be Black? The existential question for anti-racist activists, for pro-Black activists, is "How do we get free?" What does life look life when a community's identity is defined not by an apartment in Oakland, by tears and trauma and rage, but by open skies and open fields? There is fierce rage but also an equally fierce hope for communion. The Black community in their fight for dignity and justice yearn to enter a communion like T'Challa: the open expanses of all who have ever loved them and supported them to become who they are meant to be.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

"Buddhisms: An Introduction" Review

Pentecost Sunday, Year A

Coffee with Calvin in Advent: preface